Cruise ships became a bargaining chip during last week’s Barcelona City Council plenary session. Thanks to votes from Junts and ERC – exchanged for a citywide shade canopy plan alongside increased subsidies for extracurricular activities and educational support – the chamber approved a phased increase in the tourist tax levied on transit cruise passengers, set to rise from the current €4 to €24 by 2030. The administration led by Jaume Collboni has been defined by a pledge to return Barcelona to its residents, and measures such as this are devised in the hope of curtailing the impact – rather than the sheer volume – of visitors flocking to the Catalan capital. This hike has not gone unnoticed by any of the stakeholders affected by the cruise industry. Indeed, it has drawn criticism from both advocates of cruise arrivals and opponents of this form of tourism, yet both camps converge on the same core questions: Why target only transit cruise passengers? What truly distinguishes a "quality" tourist from a conventional one?
The Port of Barcelona’s 2025 annual results confirmed that cumulative cruise passengers visiting the Catalan capital reached 2.3 million. These figures, however, reflect the cruise sector as a whole, rather than just day-trippers on stopovers. Specifically, the passengers facing progressive price hikes in Barcelona up to 2030 are those who neither stay overnight nor engage in everyday city life; in other words, they dock in the morning and depart that very afternoon. By contrast, turnaround (homeport) passengers – those who embark or disembark in the Catalan capital – remain unaffected by the new measure. "The City Council is washing its hands of the issue," Daniel Pardo, a member of the Stop Creuers platform, tells The New Barcelona Post. For the civic group he represents, there should be no distinction made between passenger categories, but rather a genuine reduction in this form of travel – and in Barcelona’s tourism numbers across the board. Pardo argues that levying this surcharge exclusively on transit cruise passengers while exempting turnaround visitors is simply a way to foster one demographic at the expense of the other: "It is designed to encourage a category of tourist that spends more time in Barcelona," he says, adding that "this is what they choose to label 'quality'."
The reasoning behind the municipal distinction between passenger categories – in the assessment of consulted experts – hinges on this notion of high-value or "quality" tourism. In this view, turnaround passengers spend more time in Barcelona and disburse more money, which allegedly qualifies them as higher-calibre visitors. However, Joaquim de Toca, spokesperson for Welcome Ashore – a global, volunteer-led coalition backed by Royal Caribbean Group that gives voice to local communities affected by cruise tourism – asserts that "cruise passengers are quality tourists." In this respect, De Toca is equally puzzled by Collboni’s policy, though unlike Pardo, not because he believes all cruise traffic should be curtailed, but because, according to his data, cruise passengers account for just 2.4% of total visitors arriving in Barcelona: "Cruise ships are not the city's primary concern." Furthermore, he notes that this division between passenger categories makes little sense, as under the new levy, transit passengers "are the only tourists who pay the tax without actually sleeping in the city."
Joaquim de Toca (Welcome Ashore): "Cruise passengers are quality tourists"
So, on the one hand, Stop Creuers argues that Collboni sought to accommodate their demands, but "from the wrong angle," says Pardo, maintaining that the tax will do nothing to "reduce cruise arrivals." He also insists that policy should not revolve around deciding which types of cruise visitors are preferable: "We don't want to get into who is good and who is bad; the overall numbers must come down," the platform member stresses. De Toca, on the other hand, interprets the municipal manoeuvre as a political calculation. "I wonder whether this was pushed through because local elections are on the horizon," the Welcome Ashore spokesperson muses, reiterating that cruise travellers do not represent the city's main headache: "They do not coincide with peak periods in Barcelona’s conventional tourism calendar, and arrivals are well distributed throughout the year," De Toca points out.
Passenger spending in the city
Tourists visiting Barcelona also spend money. In this regard, the spokesperson for Welcome Ashore highlights the economic dependencies of local retailers and hospitality businesses that rely on visitor footfall. Focusing specifically on cruises, he underlines that the sector generates "a cross-cutting impact," noting that crew training academies have been established in the Catalan capital and that vessels source provisions, food, and beverages directly from Barcelona's port. "You cannot gamble with this; an enormous number of livelihoods depend on it," De Toca stresses. In his view, the advantages of cruise tourism far outweigh the drawbacks, adding that policies of this kind unfairly tarnish the image of cruise travellers: "They have been demonised ever since the tenure of Ada Colau."
Pardo disputes the notion that the benefits eclipse the downsides, maintaining that applying the surcharge solely to transit passengers will do nothing to alleviate the gentrification gripping the city. He also argues that if the council were genuinely committed to an effective strategy, "they would explicitly state an aim to curb the overall impact." For Stop Creuers, City Hall "is merely seeking to placate public discontent." At the same time, Pardo points out that cruise passengers, particularly homeport travellers, frequently arrive in Barcelona by air and stay for a few days, which the platform regards as "neither quality nor sustainable tourism." It is an assessment contested by De Toca, who places airport connections firmly on the asset side of the ledger.
Clashes over housing
Undoubtedly, the most heated battleground remains the housing crisis. According to Pardo’s estimates, homeport passengers – who are currently exempt from the incoming surcharge – spend several days in the Catalan capital and "exert even greater pressure on the housing market." For Stop Creuers, the right to housing cannot be safeguarded without first achieving a meaningful reduction in the total number of tourists – in this case, turnaround cruise travellers – visiting Barcelona each year. De Toca, for his part, denies that the majority of turnaround passengers stay in short-term tourist flats across the capital, specifying that "according to the studies we have examined, virtually all of them stay in hotels."
Daniel Pardo (Stop Creuers): "They exert even greater pressure on the housing market"
In short, Collboni is pursuing "quality tourism," and this tax serves as his vehicle to achieve it. Even so, neither critics nor advocates of the cruise sector are convinced the measure will deliver the intended results. Indeed, Pardo goes further, arguing that the regulation is an attempt to appease local residents and quell public unrest in order to continue "promoting tourism." "They want calm because tourism cannot thrive amidst social friction," he concludes.
Add The New Barcelona Post as your preferred Google source for free
Stay informed with the latest news.


