Every 17 October, Barcelona commemorates one of the most significant dates in its recent history. On that day in 1986, in Lausanne, Joan Antoni Samaranch uttered the words that would alter the city’s destiny: “À la ville de... Barcelona!”. Forty years on, we still recall that moment with genuine emotion, as though the history of contemporary Barcelona were inevitably split into a before and an after that Olympic nomination.
Thousands of pages have been written about what the 1992 Games meant. We have exported our model, hosted delegations from around the world eager to replicate it, and turned the Olympics into a kind of founding myth of modern Barcelona. Yet there is one question I have never seen us ask ourselves: what happened to the other five cities that lost out that day?
For Barcelona was not running alone. Paris, Brisbane, Belgrade, Birmingham, and Amsterdam also bid to host the 1992 Games – five cities with vastly different histories, sizes, and ambitions, yet united by the conviction that staging the planet’s foremost sporting event could help them build a better future. Barcelona won, and the others went home empty-handed. Yet life went on.
Paris, which finished runner-up, remained Paris: one of the world’s great capitals, wielding a cultural, economic, and political pull that scarcely depended on the Olympic Games. In fact, it eventually staged them in 2024, thirty-two years after Barcelona. In the meantime, it has driven major urban transformations, from the clean-up of the Seine to sweeping new metropolitan infrastructure. Yet neither its global city status nor its ambitious housing policies have spared it from immense property pressure. Segregation between the urban core and much of the metropolitan periphery likewise remains one of its defining challenges – an issue I explored in a previous article.
Brisbane, third in that ballot, has also gone on to win the Games, which it will host in 2032. Over these four decades, however, it has hardly sat around waiting for them, growing and consolidating itself as one of Australia’s leading metropolises. Strikingly, as it now prepares for the Olympic event, one of its chief concerns is preventing the Games from worsening the housing crisis. A 2025 report by the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute warns of worsening housing affordability, the disappearance of low-cost homes, and the risk of displacing vulnerable populations. In just one year, the number of people turning to homelessness support services has risen by 20%. It is telling that, six years ahead of the Games, researchers are already examining how to stop a major opportunity for urban transformation from pricing out some of the city’s own residents.
Belgrade’s story could scarcely be more different. When it submitted its bid, it was the capital of a still-united Yugoslavia aspiring to carve out its own role on the world stage. A few years later, the country disintegrated in a succession of wars that left tens of thousands dead, triggered mass displacement, and inflicted deep political and social wounds. Belgrade itself endured NATO bombings in 1999. One could hardly imagine a trajectory further removed from what the promoters of the Olympic bid had envisioned. And yet the city has pressed forward, rebuilding itself and seeking out new opportunities. One of its flagship contemporary urban schemes, Belgrade Waterfront, is transforming the riverfront into a luxury residential and business district, where apartment prices have topped €10,000 per square metre – a development that has sparked controversy over its impact on urban heritage, pre-existing activities, and housing affordability. After everything it has lived through, Belgrade too has entered the orbit of large-scale global real estate ventures.
Birmingham is probably the city that bore the closest resemblance to 1980s Barcelona: a former industrial powerhouse hit hard by economic downturn and searching for reinvention. Without the Olympics, it still pushed through major urban regeneration, overhauled its city centre, and reinforced its standing as a major British city, even hosting the Commonwealth Games in 2022. Yet physical renewal has not been matched by a comparable improvement in living standards across its entire population. According to municipal figures, at the end of the 2024–2025 financial year, more than 11,000 children were living in temporary accommodation with their families, while the city council itself slid into a severe financial crisis in 2023 – proof that physically transforming a city and guaranteeing its social and institutional prosperity are two very different things.
And finally Amsterdam, eliminated in the opening round of voting. Without needing to stage another Olympics, the Dutch capital has established itself as an international pace-setter in sustainable mobility, urban quality, and innovation – as well as in tourist appeal, to the extent that one of its foremost headaches today is curbing the impact of visitors on daily life. According to research published this year by the University of Amsterdam, the historic centre, home to roughly 80,000 residents, bears the brunt of a tourist influx reaching 22 million annual visitors across the city as a whole. Pressure on housing, the replacement of local shops, and the changing character of neighbourhoods have prompted the council to restrict new tourist-oriented businesses and propose measures to restore the balance between residents and visitors. Amsterdam has thus become a city that, after years of striving to make itself attractive, now needs to place limits on its own success.
“Barcelona made extraordinary use of the Olympic opportunity, but it would be naive to credit the Games with everything that followed”
Six cities. Six distinct trajectories. A single Olympic winner in 1986. Yet forty years later, can we really speak of winners and losers?
That question has no simple answer (or would demand an in-depth analysis I have yet to come across anywhere). What we do know is that Barcelona made extraordinary use of the Olympic opportunity, but it would be naive to credit the Games with everything that followed. A substantial share of those transformations had already been mapped out in earlier urban planning and reflected a clear political and civic determination to modernise the city. The Olympics supplied a shared horizon, financial resources, concerted agreements among key stakeholders, and, above all, a hard deadline that forced action. They acted as a powerful catalyst, yet nothing would have been achieved through them alone.
By the same token, it would be absurd to claim the other cities were doomed by not being chosen. Some have prospered markedly, others have weathered deep crises, and all have undergone transformations driven by economic, social, political, and geopolitical forces far more potent than an Olympic nomination.
Most tellingly, however, is the extent to which these cities share the very same anxieties today. Amsterdam is trying to rein in tourist pressure threatening the daily rhythm of its neighbourhoods. Paris, despite boasting a far larger social housing stock than ours, faces hundreds of thousands of applications on its waiting lists. Birmingham has thousands of families living in temporary accommodation. Belgrade is watching the regeneration of its waterfront turn into a luxury real estate play. And Brisbane is already studying how to stop the Games from exacerbating housing affordability problems. Having hosted the Olympics has not immunised us against any of these ills. Not hosting them has not prevented other cities from finding pathways to development only to end up in much the same place.
For decades, we have taken it as a given that cities had to compete against one another to attract investment, talent, tourists, and mega-events, as though there were a universal league table to climb. In many ways, the Olympic Games represented the ultimate prize in that race. Barcelona captured it and became an internationally admired model. Today it has every reason to take pride in what it achieved; after all, only one city could win in Lausanne that day, the competition was fierce, and Barcelona pulled it off.
Yet cities are not athletes vying for a medal. They are, first and foremost, places where millions of people live – people who need affordable housing, decent work, quality public services, and a healthy environment. And a city’s success should be measured neither by the number of events it stages nor by its standing in international rankings, but by its capacity to guarantee those living conditions. We have ample proof that a city can become wildly attractive to the outside world without being sufficiently liveable for its own residents. Barcelona knows this all too well – though, as we have seen, it is far from alone.
“If cities have spent decades competing to attract investment, talent, tourists, and major events, they ought now to devote at least as much energy to cooperating on challenges none can solve alone”
Perhaps, then, the time has come to change the rules of the game. If cities have spent decades competing to attract investment, talent, tourists, and major events, they ought now to devote at least as much energy to cooperating on challenges none can solve alone. Pooling knowledge, experimenting jointly with new policies, and, above all, asserting their collective strength vis-à-vis nation states and major global economic actors may prove far more rewarding than chasing top spots in international league tables. After all, the problems we share know no borders, and neither should our solutions.
Because, unlike an Olympic bid, in the race to make cities more liveable, nobody has to lose for the rest to win.